Supplier QualificationFor procurement7 min read

SIL Certificates: What to Check Before You Buy Safety Instruments and Valves

A SIL certificate says a device can be used in a safety function up to a stated level, under conditions. It does not make your loop SIL 2. Here is what to check before you buy.

TC

The ChemCapital Editorial Team

Procurement Intelligence · · Updated

Share
Blueprint style graphic of a SIL certificate card with fields for device and version, SIL capability, systematic capability, failure data, safety manual and assessor, linked to a transmitter and a valve, with the conditions field highlighted in amber
The certificate is about the device. The SIL belongs to the whole safety function. Image credit: ChemCapital

A SIL certificate for a transmitter, logic solver or valve says that the device, in a stated version and under stated conditions, can be used in a safety function up to a given safety integrity level. It does not say your safety function achieves that level. Before you buy, check the device and version match, the SIL capability and systematic capability, the failure data, the safety manual and its conditions, and who assessed it.

Why this matters now

Safety instrumented systems in UK process plants are judged against BS EN 61511, which HSE describes as the benchmark for managing functional safety in the process industries, built on BS EN 61508 as the general benchmark of good practice [1]. Buyers increasingly receive SIL certificates with bids for transmitters, valves and actuators, and few procurement teams know what to check. A wrong assumption here is not a commercial mistake; it can leave a safety function weaker than the hazard study requires.

Create and manage RFQs in minutes

ChemCapital handles the entire procurement cycle, from structured RFQs and supplier comparisons to formal purchase orders and delivery tracking.

Start for free

What a SIL is, and is not

A safety integrity level is one of four levels for the integrity required of a safety function, SIL 1 the lowest and SIL 4 the highest. IEC describes SIL as a property of a safety function, set from the tolerable risk, with higher levels giving greater risk reduction [2]. In low demand mode the bands correspond to risk reduction factors of more than 10 up to 100 for SIL 1, more than 100 up to 1,000 for SIL 2, and more than 1,000 up to 10,000 for SIL 3 [2].

So a device does not have a SIL; the safety function does. A device has a SIL capability: the highest level it can support when used as the certificate and safety manual describe [3].

Certification itself is not mandatory. Neither IEC 61508 nor IEC 61511 requires certified devices; IEC 61511 asks for evidence that a device is suitable and reliable enough, and an end user can justify a device by its own documented prior use instead [3]. A certificate is simply the most common way suppliers provide that evidence.

What to check on the certificate

CheckWhat to look forWhy it matters
Device and versionExact model, options, firmware and hardware revisionA certificate for one variant does not cover another
SIL capabilityThe maximum SIL, and for which architectureCapability may differ for single use and redundant use
Systematic capabilitySC 1 to SC 4Confidence the device is free of design faults for that SIL
Failure dataDangerous failure rates, diagnostic coverage, proof test assumptionsYour engineers need these to calculate the loop
Safety manualReferenced by number and revisionThe conditions of use live here
RouteHow compliance was shown: design to the standard or proven in useTells you what the evidence rests on
Assessor and dateWho assessed it, their independence, and whenExpired or self issued claims carry less weight

Systematic capability. It measures, on a scale of SC 1 to SC 4, the confidence that a device's systematic safety integrity meets a given SIL, provided it is used as the safety manual says. SC n corresponds to SIL n. The device's SIL capability is limited by the lower of its systematic capability and its hardware architectural constraints [4].

Redundancy has rules. Two devices of SC 2 combined can be credited at most one level higher, SC 3, and only with sufficient, justified independence between them [4]. A buyer cannot buy two SIL 2 transmitters and assume a SIL 3 loop.

Independent assessment. Systematic capability must be assessed through a functional safety assessment by an independent assessor [4]. A supplier's own declaration is not the same thing. Check the assessor's name, their accreditation, and the certificate's date and validity.

SIL certificate checklist linked to a safety function: sensor, logic solver and final element each carry their own certificate with device version, SIL capability, systematic capability, failure data and safety manual; the safety function's SIL is calculated for the whole loop by the user's engineers

What the certificate does not tell you

  • That your loop meets its SIL. The required SIL comes from your risk assessment, and the achieved SIL depends on every element, the architecture, the proof test interval and how it is maintained [3] [5].
  • That your application matches the assumptions. Process fluid, temperature, proof test method and installation all appear as conditions in the safety manual. Break one and the claim may not hold.
  • That the supplier manages functional safety well. The 61508 Association reminds directors that a certified expert is not proof of functional safety management, and that suppliers and their supply chains should demonstrate it [6].
  • Anything about systematic failures in your own design. Specification errors, software mistakes and maintenance errors are controlled by your own procedures, not by the device certificate [5].

Red flags in a SIL certificate

  • A product family, not a model. "Series X, SIL 3" with no model codes or options leaves you guessing whether your variant is covered.
  • No safety manual reference. Without it, nobody can check the conditions of use.
  • SIL capability with no systematic capability. The two go together; one without the other tells you half the story.
  • Failure data missing or only on request. Your engineers cannot calculate the loop without it.
  • A self declaration presented as a certificate. Check that an independent assessor issued it.
  • An old date and no statement of validity. Ask whether the assessment still covers the current hardware and firmware.

None of these automatically rules a device out. Each is a question to raise in technical clarification before award, not after the device is installed and the loop is already in service.

Valves need extra care

A final element is usually an assembly: valve, actuator, solenoid and sometimes a positioner, often from different makers. Each may carry its own certificate, with its own assumptions. Ask who has assessed the assembly as a whole, who provides the combined failure data, and which proof test, such as a full or partial stroke test, the figures assume. Final elements often dominate the loop's failure probability, as the example below shows. Note that an instrumented trip is a different layer of protection from mechanical relief; our guide to safety valves, relief valves and bursting discs covers the mechanical side.

Practical example

Illustrative figures. A SIL 2 high pressure trip uses one pressure transmitter, one logic solver and one shutdown valve assembly. The engineers calculate each element's average probability of failure on demand, using certificate failure data and a one year proof test interval.

ElementAverage probability of failure on demand
Pressure transmitter0.0004
Logic solver0.0001
Valve assembly0.0035
Total for the function0.0040
Risk reduction factor1 ÷ 0.0040 = 250, within SIL 2 (100 to 1,000)

Now suppose the plant wants a two year proof test interval for the valve. With the simplified approximation that average failure probability is about the dangerous undetected failure rate times half the test interval, the valve's figure doubles to about 0.0070, the total becomes 0.0075, and the risk reduction factor falls to about 133. It is still SIL 2, but with far less margin, and the result depends on the valve certificate's failure rate. Your safety engineers do the real calculation; procurement's job is to make sure the certificates and safety manuals they need arrive with the bids.

What to put in the RFQ

  • The safety function's required SIL and whether the device is in a safety loop.
  • A request for the SIL certificate, the safety manual and the failure data for the exact model and options offered.
  • The assessor's identity and the certificate's validity.
  • For valves, assembly level data covering valve, actuator and solenoid, and the proof test assumed.
  • Confirmation that the offered version matches the certificate.

When bids arrive, ChemCapital's AI quotation comparison lines up each bid's certificates, versions and exclusions side by side, so a missing safety manual or a mismatched model stands out before award. Our instrument datasheet template shows where SIL requirements sit on the datasheet.

Where ChemCapital fits

Safety devices are where a missing document matters most. Structured RFQs that ask for the same evidence from every bidder make the check routine instead of a scramble at FAT.

Ready to buy safety instruments and valves with the right evidence in every bid? Start a free 14 day ChemCapital trial, with no credit card needed.

Frequently asked questions

What does a SIL certificate mean?

That a device, in a stated version and under the conditions of its safety manual, can be used in a safety function up to a stated SIL. It does not mean the safety function achieves that SIL; that depends on the whole loop.

Is SIL certification mandatory?

No. IEC 61508 and IEC 61511 do not require certified devices. IEC 61511 requires evidence that a device is suitable, which can come from a certificate or from the user's documented prior use.

What is systematic capability?

A rating from SC 1 to SC 4 of confidence that a device's design is free enough of systematic faults for use at that SIL, provided it is used as its safety manual says. SC 2 corresponds to SIL 2.

Can two SIL 2 devices make a SIL 3 loop?

Not automatically. Combining elements can raise systematic capability by at most one level, and only with sufficient, justified independence between them. The whole loop must still be calculated.

What should I ask a valve supplier for in a SIL application?

Certificates and failure data for the valve, actuator and solenoid as an assembly, the safety manual, the proof test assumed, and the assessor's details.

Informational only, not procurement or legal advice. Cited names, frameworks, and statistics belong to their respective owners.

Share this article

Send it to a colleague or stakeholder.

Create and manage RFQs in minutes

ChemCapital handles the entire procurement cycle, from structured RFQs and supplier comparisons to formal purchase orders and delivery tracking.

Start for free

Related articles